My favorite performance of the Top 18:
The move from the top 18 to the top 18 meant two painful and confusing cuts. Lost from the girls was Ashley, and from the guys, Max. Ashley seemed like a pretty good dancer, and I felt for her because she had tried out so many times, only to be cut from the top 18. Ouch. And it wasn’t even her fault she was in the bottom 3! Kupono, her partner, destroyed the routine, which wasn’t that great to begin with- I’m sorry, bu Shane Sparks is no Tabitha and Napoleon. Max getting cut made sense- he doesn’t fit the young, Zac Efron-cute, contemporary or hip-hop mold of male dancers. He just wasn’t right, and it’s a shame because I love the male Russian ballroom dancers. Pasha is my favorite SYTYCD contestant yet. But I digress, someone had to be cut.
Ashley’s solo was definitely the weakest, with just some posing by the stairs- always a deadly solo move. But I think Max’s ballroom “Footloose” routine had more substance that Kupono’s spiritedly quirky solo. Kupono should’ve left, but he was a more intriguing character, and after all, SYTYCD is a television show for America’s favorite dancer, not the best.
That leaves Kupono and Kayla as a couple, and I think they’re going to emerge as a power couple. Both are strong dancers, who have bright personalities and are attractive. Reminds me of Chelsie and Mark from last year, another girlie blond and quirky Hawaiian duo, who made it pretty far…
TOP 16 RANKINGS
- Janette & Brandon- two smashing performances to date, and not exactly in the most entertaining genres
- Karla & Jonathan- an amazing comeback from the first week with the best performance of week two
- Jeanine & Phillip- they were dreadful this week, but Phillip is definitely the most beloved dancer this season
- Melissa & Ade- two weeks of strong performances, but I fear they’re not compelling enough personality-wise
- Randi & Evan- these two are cute and have chemistry, and I think they’ll bounce back quickly
- Kayla & Kupono- a new partnership with huge potential
- Caitlin & Jason- they are cute together, but I think they don’t have long-term potential…
- Asuka & Vitolio- the waltz was okay, but not tear-worthy, and I think they’re in serious trouble




